Confident Apple for 2004
by Derrick Story 01/07/2004What do you do when the whole world is watching and you don't have a killer hardware announcement? You do what Steve did on the opening day of Macworld 2004.
Steve Jobs’ first keynote of the year was relaxed, confident, and entertaining. And to me, it was a keynote for Apple in 2004 as much as it was for the Macworld conference.
You might be thinking that the iPod mini isn't exactly chopped liver and qualifies as a major hardware announcement. You're right, it isn't chopped liver. It's cool. It's five fruity flavors in your pocket. But it's an evolution of a revolutionary product. In of itself, the iPod mini isn't a major announcement. Apple is tending the garden, and they are doing so quite well.
Then you could argue that the Xserve G5 isn't really anything to pooh-pooh. And I would say, "Amen brother." The Xserve is Apple's commitment to the small and large enterprise market -- and what a beautiful, smart, powerful commitment it is. And don't forget about the Xserve RAID Steve demoed. Very nice.
Again, evolutionary, not revolutionary. Nothing wrong with that. In fact, nothing worse than having a great idea (iPod, Xserve, etc.) and not fully developing it. Apple is not only coming up with new ideas, but they are also seeing them through. Heck, look at Mac OS X if you want to talk commitment. This is good business.
|
|
While I'm standing here in the garden that Apple is tending, I should mention the iLife suite. iPhoto, iDVD, iTunes, and iMovie are all maturing with grace and stability. It's so cool to fire up a new version of a favorite application and not be disgusted by feature bloat, poor performance, and buggy behavior.
I haven't heard the official word either way on this, but it appears that you will have to buy iLife to get the updated versions of iPhoto, etc. No more free downloads apparently. But the entire suite is $49 and that includes a new application that is killer. Personally, I find it hard to complain about that.
But I want to get back to the keynote itself and Apple's momentum for 2004. One of the first things I noticed during the presentation was that it was mostly Steve and a few Apple product managers. The parade of technology CEOs proclaiming their commitment to the Mac platform was diverted to another place and time. Yes, Microsoft did make an appearance to announce Office 2004 for the Mac. And that was certainly the right thing to do. But that's all that was needed. Apple doesn't require validation from fickle companies that would just as easily turn away at the drop of a mouse.
|
|
Steve ran most of the demos. And watching him refer to his notes, leg bouncing with excitement as he tried to tame his computer in front of the whole world was exciting. Steve is a rock star, no doubt. But there's something very endearing about him when he sits down at the computer and suddenly becomes you or me trying to make something happen. It takes guts to do that in front of the whole world. And when it works, we can identify with the man on the stage in a very familiar way. If Steve can do it in front of thousands, millions, of people, then I sure as hell can in the privacy of my own office.
It got even better. Steve introduced John Mayer. John has some endearing qualities himself. First of all, he's a guitar player, and the first thing they did was set him down at the keyboard. "John, play a few rifts for us," Steve asked. John's thinking, "Dang, what am I doing playing the keyboard in front of the whole world." But it worked. Again, it was you or me trying to pound out a tune.
|
|
The new application, GarageBand was the reason for all this fun. And what a heck of a program it is. Over and over again I heard in the audience, "I want that." You look at it, watch Steve trying to shape a composition with it, and you connect. Not only is the application revolutionary (because average people can actually use it), so was the presentation of it.
Then they got serious. John Mayer picked up the guitar and the room lit up. I cannot describe the enjoyment I felt watching John play, Steve play, and seeing the Mac capture it all. When Steve was getting ready to close the application, "Save it!" was shouted throughout the hall.
|
|
I don't know what's going to happen in 2004. I hope it's a good year for the U.S. and all of the world. But I do know that Apple has laid the foundation for a strong 12 months ahead. You can see it on paper, and I could feel it in the Moscone Ballroom yesterday.
Now we need to do our part. We need to take this platform and push it to the very limit. As developers and power users, we can apply the same creativity and confidence to our endeavors that Apple has to its framework.
|
|
When Steve introduced the video showing Virginia Tech's supercluster of 1,100 G5s, I thought that this is a perfect example of recognizing the strengths of a platform and leveraging it in a creative way. I would love to see those types of achievements, big and small, come out of our audience. We certainly can add fuel to this fire, and if we do, God knows what we might see this time next year.
Derrick Story is the digital media evangelist for O'Reilly. He is the author of The Photoshop CS4 Companion for Photographers, The Digital Photography Companion, and Digital Photography Hacks, and coauthor of iPhoto: The Missing Manual, with David Pogue. You can follow him on Twitter or visit www.thedigitalstory.com.
Return to the Mac DevCenter
You must be logged in to the O'Reilly Network to post a talkback.
Showing messages 1 through 34 of 34.
-
Photo expert? Artist?
2004-01-16 08:58:03 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
-
Photo expert? Artist?
2004-01-16 09:10:20 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
yes, i agree with the previous poster. the pictures make steve's head look like that drippin' snot monster thing in the alien movies starring the sigourneys weaver. i have seen steve (and his impressive line of turtlenecks) in person and I can vouch for the fact his head does not even look closely in shape to that of the monster in any of the alien movies. i'm afraid that the author's photo books might also tend to teach how to make those horrible no-so-steady cam shots that cause nausea on MTV and other terribly produced cable shows. I will have to stay away too. -
Photo expert? Artist?
2004-01-16 12:28:06 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I have his book on digital photography and it's a good one. The photos in it don't look anything like the ones here. I bet he wasn't close enough to the stage to take a close up. These look like shots from the screens they may have had in the room.
Look at his pictures from previous articles and blogs. They're just fine. -
RE: Photo expert? Artist?
2004-01-16 13:10:01 Derrick Story [Reply | View]
Geez...
OK, here's the story. On the day of the keynote I had an all day tutorial that I was teaching for Macworld on Digital Photography. The tutorial started at 11 am. I knew Steve wouldn't be done in time for me to go set up for the all day class, so I would have to leave early.
So I sat more in the back of the hall so as not to disturb others when I had to leave while the event was underway. That's called being polite. Even though I wasn't in the first row, I thought some of our readers might like to see a few images to accompany the article, so I took pictures off the screens.
I left the hall at 10:40, as I knew I would have to, and had a full classroom of students ready for me to start on time at 11:00, which I did.
If you guys read my books, you'll learn that I encourage creative problem solving, so that no matter the circumstances, you get the shot.
I appreciate the one poster that gave me the benefit of the doubt.
-
The real keynote during the super bowl?
2004-01-12 06:28:30 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I know this is a stretch. But I would watch the super bowl this year. Perhaps that is where the big announcement for hardware is going to be announced. It was twenty years ago during the big game the hardware was announced. Perhaps steve showing the add at Mac World was a hint.
-
The Band
2004-01-08 18:37:41 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
To know what craftmanship is just look at Gates presentation of the DvD player he showed at CES. He used a sales guy to show it off....just pathic. Then Steve shows off GarageBand..he does the presentation with help with John Mayer! All passion and craftmenship.
-
Glad to see the positive view
2004-01-08 13:04:57 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I'm glad to see a positive review of the keynote. Like you said, it was mostly evolutionary and that's extremerly positive - "evolve or die!". Not all keynotes has to be a bootstompping, heartripping experience to leave one with a nice afterglow.
-
Recording minutes of live music before millions of eyes...
2004-01-08 11:18:07 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
That was the most exciting thing about the keynote.
They demoed a brand new app, recording minutes of music!
That was incredibly risky, I'd say. So much could have gone wrong.
There is no person on the world who'd take the risk of demoing a music program like that on a PC.
That was the most striking demonstration of reliability I've ever seen.
-
MWSF - Yawn
2004-01-08 10:34:37 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Not much intersting this year. No faster G5's, no updated iMacs or eMacs, no 20th Anv. Mac.
-
the missing point...
2004-01-08 10:12:44 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
In the past Apple announced many products and they would get lost in the ... but one last thing (iMac 2) shuffle.
I found the show, to be well thought out. They wanted to focus on music and ipods. If they had come out with a 3 GHz station everyone would have forgotten iLife.
I remember buying a pc and their were so many to choose from I just left. The next store had just a couple and it was a lot easier.
My two bits, thanks
-
Keynote and GB
2004-01-08 08:45:12 reluctantswitcher [Reply | View]
It was an excellent keynote with some strong but largely evolutionary announcements. However, GarageBand is, IMHO, a "killer app". My kids are alreadt planning their music, CDs and pop videos, all using one platform. GB alone is easily worth $49 and that fact that you get iMovie with trim-editing, iPhoto with performance and database size improvements, iTunes with Rendevouz sharing, etc, etc - is great ! Pity iDVD still only links to Superdrives. BTW, I wonder when GarageBand, linked to iTunes, will allow upload, as well as download - just imagine ! :-) -
Keynote and GB
2004-01-08 10:00:44 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
"I wonder when ... iTunes, will allow upload ... just imagine !"
Oooh! Cool! A section of the iTMS for user-submitted tracks. With a fair royalty process, paid directly to the submitter, in-home composers can make a few bucks while refining their skills. Meanwhile, Apple gets to keep more of the per-track price (or lower the price and keep the same share).
There are some hurdles Apple would have to choose to overcome, but they're not particularly technical -- more policy and staffing related:
1. Pre-screening submissions to make sure they are original recordings, not just uploads of copyrighted works. Not sure how this applies to new recordings of copyrighted lyrics, arrangements, etc. [An introducton to these rules would be helpful.] Perhaps including a stiff penalty (with a fair investigation proces) for violators.
2. Determining a valid quality threshold for submissions. The iTMS is successful, in part, because the recordings it offers are consistently high quality versions. Would even 10% of amateur recordings have high enough quality?
3. Deciding how to pay submitters. iTMS credits? Apple Store credits? Credit Card refunds?
Challenges, yes. And I'm sure there are more to consider. But there is great potential in this idea. I'll certainly look forward to seeing this feature in next year's Keynote. -
iTMS Uploading
2004-01-09 11:33:41 tpherndon [Reply | View]
Apple will very likely never allow direct uploading to iTMS. However, it is *trivially* easy to go through an independent distributor label such as (amongst others) cdbaby.net, who will happily set you up with both a CD and internet music service distribution deal. I am not 100% sure that cdbaby does iTMS, it isn't explicitly listed in their marketing blurb, but if not, I know there are other similar services out there.
Go check it out. -
Keynote and GB
2004-01-08 20:05:29 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
This uploading to iTMS is eons away from happening. Apple is not going to pay for reviewers and/or screeners because submissions would be quite too many.
HOWEVER, I think it is very likely that soon you will be able to "share" your creations easily to your .mac homepage; another possiblity that justifies $99 per year. By "share" I mean clicking on a menu just like iPhoto or iMovie; of course you can work around and post it to your homepage. -
Keynote and GB
2004-01-08 20:05:00 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
This uploading to iTMS is eons away from happening. Apple is not going to pay for reviewers and/or screeners because submissions would be quite too many. HOWEVER, I think it is very likely that soon you will be able to "share" your creations easily to your .mac homepage; another possiblity that justifies $99 per year. By "share" I mean clicking on a menu just like iPhoto or iMovie; of course you can work around and post it to your homepage.
-
Charging for iPhoto and iMovie is wrong
2004-01-08 07:20:23 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I disagree with the practice of charging for iPhoto and iMovie. People who have had their Mac's for some time operated under the impression that the original i products where a part of the OS. Each iteration of the products was a free download. The only exception being iDVD, although I can justify it due to the size of the download.
Now I have all of my content in these applications and have become a regular part of my computing experience. Now that I'm hooked in Apple is going to start charging for them. I think it's wrong. Banks allowed ATM usage to be free, once users became hooked they started charging. Drug dealers operate the same way, first hit free. Once your addicted they start to charge.
That's my 2 cents.
-
Analogies considered harmful
2004-01-08 07:57:11 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
You're not being charged for things you already have, which will continue to work for years, you're being charged for a new upgraded package of apps. Just how many upgrades did you expect to get, upgrades for life?
Your ATM analogy, like your drug-dealer one, is rendered irrelevant by the fact that these apps are not a service or consumable product which is being charged for after a free trial period. You can continue to use the old versions as long as you like. I can't believe people would complain about $49 for GarageBand, let alone a whole suite.
That would be once *you're* addicted if you must use comparisons with a world most of us have never experienced, perhaps you could add the word 'crack' to complete that Slashdot experience? -
Analogies considered harmful
2004-01-10 07:07:42 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
For the record I don't read slashdot or do drugs. But I like the analogy.
You make a good point about ATM's being consumable products and pointing out the difference in regards to the iApps. I can't argue with your logic on that point. I also have no problem with them charging for GarageBand and the iDVD upgrade.
My complaint lies in that I received free upgrades with the last release of iMovie and iPhoto. I was also under the impression that the products were a part of the OS, not a separate application that was given away for free. You couldn't buy the iApps separately when they were released, they were a part of every Mac. I get free upgrades for Jaguar, why not expect free upgrades for other applications that I was led to believe where a part of Jaguar.
The short point is that if the iApps where sold as a free add-on with the purchase of a Mac then I wouldn't expect free upgrades. They were sold as a part of the Mac and removing functionality in order to charge for it is where my complaint lies.
Are they going to start charging 19.99 for Safari?
-
iLife bundled?
2004-01-08 06:11:18 bazzargh [Reply | View]
According to the transcript I was reading (IRC provided my MacRumours.com) iLife4 is being bundled with all new Macs, from the 16th? Anyone know if that is being reported elsewhere?
Its impossible to tell from Apples online store what software will be bundled - they don't even tell you the version of OSX you'll get. Ah well, I ordered my new powerbook yesterday anyway, I'm sure I'll get iLife eventually... -
iLife bundled?
2004-01-09 11:36:50 tpherndon [Reply | View]
Not the 16th, the 6th. As in, keynote day. You should either get it with your new PB (congrats, BTW, and I'm envious), or you should get a fulfillment coupon or something like that. -
iLife bundled?
2004-01-08 08:26:55 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Steve definately said that iLife is bundled free with new Mac purchases - presumably that's after the product is actually release in a couple of weeks, but if you order a machine between now and then you'll be eligible for iLife for free. -
iLife bundled?
2004-01-12 04:19:33 esc [Reply | View]
I was in an AppleStore over the weekend. iLife is not on the Macs sitting around in the store. According to a sales person it will be available in boxes and perhaps on some Macs on 1/16. If you buy a Mac after the announcement and iLife isn't included, you can fill out a form and pay $20 to get a copy sent to you. The clerk said they would not hand you a box in the store. This is similar to earlier Apple policy (old machines without Panther for example)
-
Growing confidence in evidence
2004-01-07 20:40:49 msievers [Reply | View]
With the stress of moving the Mac customer base to OSX starting to fade in the rear view mirror, Apple can now turn its attention to tying together the many technologies it has to offer. While we often see the power of an individual innovation we only gradually come to realize how all the pieces of the puzzle fit together to create a whole that is greater than its parts. Xgrid and Rendezvous are examples of the kind of synergy we will all enjoy going forward. I sense the growing confidence in this year's MacWorld keynote and yes, the year ahead is very promising.
-
iLife
2004-01-07 17:48:56 mike3k [Reply | View]
iTunes & iPhoto are the only iLife apps I use regularly. Although both my PowerBook & G4 towers have SuperDrives, I never use iDVD or iMovie, since I don't have any video equipment and I'm not interested in making movies.
I would love to be able to get just iPhoto as a free download. I really don't care about getting the rest of the package.
-
best commentary yet
2004-01-07 17:30:56 restiffbard [Reply | View]
Thanks, Derrick. That has to be the best commentary yet on this year's MacWorld. Reading the rumor forums lately has been making me insane with all the complaints. I thought it was great. GarageBand is incredible. John Mayer was perfect. Steve was, as usual, great to watch. I enjoyed it thoroughly. Also, I switched less than a year ago, from Linux. I've no complaints. Thanks for not continuing the trash talking I've been seeing. -
best commentary yet
2004-01-08 01:24:06 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I also think the forum-folk have been too hard. They were all expecting $100 ipods and that wasn't going to happen...not this macworld!
I personally thought it was a pretty good keynote. I too would've liked a free iphoto download but as I play guitar I'll probably play with Garageband so the iLife price is worth it.
BTW, I'm also a Linux->Mac switcher so you're not alone -
best commentary yet
2004-01-12 20:53:43 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
total agreement. it was like the days when the small speed bumps of powermacs made people want to rip their hair off. sometimes the rumors take a life of their own and people just assume that what is being touted is fact. i just saws the keynote online for the first time and was just smiling in enjoyment of the festivities. There was an air of this thing continuing all year. I wouldn't be too afraid to say that this is a yearlong Keynote. Last year was a breakthrough year for developers, this year for the larger section of consumers and even enterprise. Kinda of a rebirth for apple in a sense.






The photos to this article are all distorted when I view them. Twisted or skewed is the best way to describe them.
Now this article is written by someone who is supposed to be an expert in Digital Photography? Huh? Are you trying to be "creative"? Artistic?
It does not inspire me to go buy your book.